My SEO site lost 82 percent of its impressions in two weeks and kept every click
In September 2025 my impressions collapsed while clicks rose. A restaurant site lost far less, and a poetry site lost nothing.
An impression is counted whenever your page appears in a result that loads, even if nobody scrolls to it. Rank-tracking tools load results to check positions, so their checks could be counted too.
Why it matters
When that stopped, sites lost the views that tools had been creating. My SEO site lost 82 percent, because SEO searches are exactly what SEO tools track. A restaurant site lost 38 percent. My poetry site kept growing.
The average position also jumped from about 60 to about 30, not because rankings improved, but because the deep, tool-made views disappeared.
How to check your own site
- In Search Console, compare 1 to 31 August 2025 with 15 September to 15 October 2025.
- If impressions fell and clicks did not, the lost views were never real visitors.
At a glance
On SEO topics, a large share of impressions came from tools, not people. Sites about SEO are checked by tools all day, so they lost the most. I now trust clicks over impressions for anything before that week.
- Publishing my topical map multiplied impressions by almost five, and clicks went down12 Nov 2026
- Bing showed one of my guides 377,071 times in four weeks, and almost nobody clicked9 Nov 2026
- My audit tool said 68 of 75 pages had no meta description. They did.8 Nov 2026
- A question with a one line answer was shown 2,572 times and got no clicks3 Nov 2026
